Masterlist

Jared Padalecki

— Sam Winchester; taken

— Souless!Sam; taken

— Sam Wesson 

Jensen Ackles; taken

— Dean Winchester; taken

— Dean Smith 

Misha Collins; taken

— Castiel; taken

— Jimmy Novak

— Meta!Misha (can be as douchey as rper wishes, but don’t kill anyone) 

Jim Beaver

— Bobby Singer

Jeffery Dean Morgan

— John Winchester

Samantha Ferris

— Ellen Harvelle

Alona Tal

— Jo Harvelle

Chad Lindberg

— Ash

Mark Pellegrino

— Lucifer (Can also pick Jared and their FC because why the fuck not)

Matt Cohen

— Little John

— Michael

Richard Speight Jr.

— Gabriel; taken

Sebastian Roché

— Balthazar; taken

Genevieve Cortese

— Ruby (can FC either actress)

Mark Sheppard

— Crowley

James Patrick Stuart

— Dick Roman

Felicia Day

— Charlie Bradbury

Rob Benedict

— Chuck Shurley; taken

Jake Abel

— Adam Milligan

Kim Rhodes

— Sheriff Jody Mills

Gabriel Tigerman

— Andy

'67 Impala

— Baby

Gender swaps:

Fem!Ash; taken

Becky; taken