Jared Padalecki
— Sam Winchester; taken
— Souless!Sam; taken
— Sam Wesson
Jensen Ackles; taken
— Dean Winchester; taken
— Dean Smith
Misha Collins; taken
— Castiel; taken
— Jimmy Novak
— Meta!Misha (can be as douchey as rper wishes, but don’t kill anyone)
Jim Beaver
— Bobby Singer
Jeffery Dean Morgan
— John Winchester
Samantha Ferris
— Ellen Harvelle
Alona Tal
— Jo Harvelle
Chad Lindberg
— Ash
Mark Pellegrino
— Lucifer (Can also pick Jared and their FC because why the fuck not)
Matt Cohen
— Little John
— Michael
Richard Speight Jr.
— Gabriel; taken
Sebastian Roché
— Balthazar; taken
Genevieve Cortese
— Ruby (can FC either actress)
Mark Sheppard
— Crowley
James Patrick Stuart
— Dick Roman
Felicia Day
— Charlie Bradbury
Rob Benedict
— Chuck Shurley; taken
Jake Abel
— Adam Milligan
Kim Rhodes
— Sheriff Jody Mills
Gabriel Tigerman
— Andy
‘67 Impala
— Baby
Gender swaps:
Fem!Ash; taken
Becky; taken